Home/order

If you found this page via Google or another search engine, CLICK HERE to enter our full-featured site

Johnny Mathis
Original vinyl records

Albums are listed by release date. Grading order is cover/vinyl. Grading standards & terms

Johnny Mathis / 1956 / Columbia CL-887 mono

VG+ sps / VG+ / $20.00Record sold

His spectacular debut album, with "In Other Words," "It Might As Well Be Spring," the beautiful "Autumn in Rome," some fine minor-key work on "Love, Your Magic Spell Is Everywhere" and "Prelude To A Kiss," the exotic "Caravan" and "Babalu" and the bluesy "Angel Eyes." Liner notes by producer George Avakian, who discovered the velvet-voiced 19-year-old in a San Francisco nightclub and brought him to New York for this album. Terrific jazzy arrangements by Gil Evans, John Lewis, Teo Macero and Bob Prince. Excellent sound quality

 

Johnny Mathis

Wonderful Wonderful / 1957 / Columbia CL 1028 mono

VG++ / VG+ / $16.00

Original release, "6-eye" label

 

Johnny Mathis - Warm (original)

Johnny Mathis

Warm / 1957 / Columbia CL 1078 mono

VG++ / VG++ / $28.00

Original release, "6-eye" label. With Percy Faith & His Orchestra. Warm, My One And Only Love, Baby Baby Baby, A Handful Of Stars, By Myself, I've Grown Accustomed To Her Face, Then I'll Be Tired Of You, I'm Glad There Is You, What'll I Do, The Lovely Things You Do, There Goes My Heart, While We're Young

 

Johnny Mathis

Warm / 196? / Columbia CS 8039

VG+ / VG++ / $18.00

Reissue, "360 Stereo" in white on label. With Percy Faith & His Orchestra. Warm, My One And Only Love, Baby Baby Baby, A Handful Of Stars, By Myself, I've Grown Accustomed To Her Face, Then I'll Be Tired Of You, I'm Glad There Is You, What'll I Do, The Lovely Things You Do, There Goes My Heart, While We're Young

 

Johnny Mathis - Good Night, Dear Lord

Johnny Mathis

Goodnight, Dear Lord / 1958 / Columbia CL 1119 mono

VG++ wobc / NM / $25.00

Original release, "6-eye" label. With "Swing Low, Sweet Chariot" and two versions of "Ave Maria". Small writing on back cover.

 

Johnny Mathis

Swing Softly / 1958 / Columbia CL 1165 mono

VG++ / VG+ / $20.00

Original release, "6-eye" label. With Percy Faith & His Orchestra

 

Johnny Mathis

Johnny's Greatest Hits / 1958 / Columbia CL 1133 mono

VG+ / VG++ / $20.00

"6-eye" label. Chances Are, All The Time, The Twelfth Of Never, When Sunny Gets Blue, When I Am With You, Wonderful Wonderful!, It's Not For Me To Say, Come To Me, Wild Is The Wind, Warm And Tender, No Love, I Look At You

 

Johnny Mathis

Open Fire, Two Guitars / 1959 / Columbia CL 1270 mono

VG++ / VG++ / $25.00Record sold

Original release, "6-eye" label. With Al Caiola and Tony Mottola

 

Johnny Mathis

Heavenly / 1959 / Columbia CL 1351 mono

VG+ / VG+ / $18.00

Original release, "6-eye" label. With Hello Young Lovers, Misty, Stranger In Paradise, A Lovely Way To Spend An Evening, A Ride On A Rainbow, More Than You Know, Something I Dreamed Last Night, Moonlight Becomes You, They Say It's Wonderful, I'll Be Easy To Find, That's All. Arranged and conducted by Glen Osser

 

Johnny Mathis -More Johnny's Greatest Hits

Johnny Mathis

More Johnny's Greatest Hits / 1959 / Columbia CL 1344 mono

VG++ / VG++ / $20.00

Original release, "6-eye" label. With Small World, Someone, Very Much In Love, You Are Everything To Me, Let It Rain, The Flame Of Love, A Certain Smile, Call Me, You Are Beautiful, Teacher Teacher, Stairway To The Sea, Let's Love

 

Johnny Mathis

Faithfully / 1959 / Columbia CL 1422 mono

VG+ / NM / $18.00

Original mono release, "6-eye" label. Faithfully, Tonight, Nobody Knows, One Starry Night, Follow Me, You Better Go Now, Secret Love, Maria, Where Do You Think You're Going, And This Is My Beloved, Where Are You?, Blue Gardenia

 

Johnny Mathis

Faithfully / 1962 / Columbia CS 8219

NM is / VG++ / $18.00Record sold

'60s reissue, "360 Sound Stereo" in white print on label. Faithfully, Tonight, Nobody Knows, One Starry Night, Follow Me, You Better Go Now, Secret Love, Maria, Where Do You Think You're Going, And This Is My Beloved, Where Are You?, Blue Gardenia

 

Johnny Mathis

Johnny's Mood / 1960 / Columbia CL 1526 mono

VG / VG+ / $11.00Record sold

Original release, "6-eye" label. Cover seam taped. I'm Gonna Laugh You Out Of My Life, Stay Warm, There's No You, How High The Moon, I'm So Lost, Once, Goodnight My Love, The Folks Who Live On The Hill, April In Paris, Corner To Corner, In Return, I'm In The Mood For Love

 

Johnny Mathis

Live It Up! / 1962 / Columbia CS 8511

VG++ / VG+ / $15.00Record sold

Original release, "6-eye" label

 

Johnny Mathis

Johnny / 1963 / Columbia CS 8844

VG++ / VG+ / $15.00

Original release, "360 Sound" in black on label. Arranged & conducted by Don Costa. "Easy Does It," "The Most Beautiful Girl In The World," "Miracles," "When The World Was Young," "Never Never Land," "Poor Butterfly," "Jump For Joy," "Joey, Joey, Joey," "I Can't Believe That You're Not In Love With Me," "I Love You," "Weaver Of Dreams," No Man Can Stand Alone." Back cover shows Johnny playing tennis and basketball

 

Johnny Mathis

Rhythms Of Broadway / 1964 / Columbia CS 9023

NM is / NM / $18.00 BUY AT GREG'S GROOVES ON AMAZON MARKETPLACE

Original release, "360 Sound Stereo" in black on label. Everything's Coming Up Roses, Guys And Dolls, I Wish I Were In Love Again, You Do Something To Me, Let's Misbehave, I Could Have Danced All Night

 

New arrival Johnny Mathis

Ballads Of Broadway / 1964 / Columbia CS 9024

NM is / NM / $20.00

Original release, "360 Sound Stereo" in black on label. Moanin' Low, Fun To Be Fooled, I Have Dreamed, My Romance, Dancing On The Ceiling, I Married An Angel, Isn't It A Pity, Spring Is Here, Don't Blame Me, Taking A Chance On Love, The Party's Over, On The Sunny Side Of The Street

 

Johnny Mathis

I'll Search My Heart / 1964 / Columbia CL 2143 mono

VG++ / VG++ / $17.00Record sold

"Guaranteed High Fidelity" in black on label. With I'll Search My Heart, My Favorite Dream, All The Sad Young Men, A Clock Without Hands, Wherever You Are It's Spring, Every Step Of The Way, Sooner Or Later, What To Do About Love, Each Time We Kiss, The Joy Of Loving You, The Best of Everything, Starbright

 

Johnny Mathis

The Wonderful World Of Make Believe / 1964 / Mercury MG 20913 mono

NM / VG++ / $18.00Record sold

Custom inner sleeve

 

Johnny Mathis

Love Is Everything / 1964 / Mercury MG 20991 mono

VG+ / VG+ / $12.50Record sold

With An Affair To Remember, This Is All I Ask, Long Ago And Far Away, Never Let Me Go, Go Away Little Girl, Young And Foolish, Love Is Everything, People, One More Mountain, A Thousand Blue Bubbles, Come Ride The Wind With Me, Dancing In The Dark

 

Johnny Mathis

The Shadow Of Your Smile / 1966 / Mercury MG 21073 mono

VG++ / VG++ / $15.00Record sold

 

Johnny Mathis

The Shadow Of Your Smile / 1966 / Mercury SR 61073

VG++ / VG+ / $12.50

 

Johnny Mathis

So Nice / 1966 / Mercury SR 61091

NM / NM / $18.00Record sold

Impossible Dream, I Will Wait For You, What The World Needs Now Is Love, Hurry It's Lovely Up Here, Elusive Butterfly, So Nice, Dulcinea, What Now My Love, Man Of La Mancha, The Music That Makes Me Dance, I Dream Of You, Baubles Bangles & Beads

 

Johnny Mathis

Johnny Mathis Sings / 1967 / Mercury MG 21107 mono

NM is / VG+ / $14.00

Saturday Sunshine, Lovers In New York, Eleanor Rigby, Sunny, Who Can I Turn To, Stranges In The Night, (There's) Always Something There To Remind Me, Somewhere My Love, Who Can Say, I Wish You Love, The Second Time Around, Walk The Town And Tell The People

 

Johnny Mathis Sings

Johnny Mathis

Johnny Mathis Sings / 1967 / Mercury SR 61107

VG++ / VG++ / $15.00

Saturday Sunshine, Lovers In New York, Eleanor Rigby, Sunny, Who Can I Turn To, Stranges In The Night, (There's) Always Something There To Remind Me, Somewhere My Love, Who Can Say, I Wish You Love, The Second Time Around, Walk The Town And Tell The People. Small punch hole in corner of cover

 

Johnny Mathis

Up, Up And Away / 1967 / Columbia CS 9526

VG+ / VG++ / $12.50Record sold

Light stain on cover. Up Up And Away, The More I See You, Where Are The Words, The Morningside Of The Mountain, I Won't Cry Anymore, Far Above Cayuga's Waters, Misty Roses, Drifting, At The Crossroads, I Thought Of You Last Night, When I Look In Your Eyes

 

Johnny Mathis

Love Is Blue / 1968 / Columbia CS 9637

Sealed / $25.00Record sold

By The Time I Get To Phoenix, The Look Of Love, Here There And Everywhere, Venus, I Say A Little Prayer, Never My Love, Moon River, Don't Go Breakin' My Heart, Walk On By

 

Johnny Mathis

Love Is Blue / 1970? / Columbia CS 9637

NM is / NM / $12.50

Second issue. By The Time I Get To Phoenix, The Look Of Love, Here There And Everywhere, Venus, I Say A Little Prayer, Never My Love, Moon River, Don't Go Breakin' My Heart, Walk On By

 

Johnny Mathis

Those Were The Days / 1968 / Columbia CS 9705

VG+ / VG / $8.00Record sold

Original release, 360 Stereo on label. Little Green Apples, Light My Fire, This Guy's In Love With You, The End Of The World, The 59th Street Bridge Song (Feelin' Groovy), Turn Around Look At Me, Every Time I Dream Of You, The World I Used To Know, Those Were The Days, You Make Me Think About You

 

Johnny Mathis

The Impossible Dream / 1969 / Columbia CS 9872

NM is / VG+ / $12.00Record sold

Original release, 360 Stereo on label. Strangers In The Night, On A Clear Day You Can See Forever, Somewhere My Love, I Will Wait For You, So Nice, Go Away Little Girl, Eleanor Rigby, The Very Thought Of You, Moment To Moment, The Impossible Dream

 

Johnny Mathis

Romeo And Juliet / 1969 / Columbia CS 9909

NM is / VG+ / $12.50

Original release, "360 Stereo" on label. Factory sticker on shrink promotes I"ll Never Fall In Love Again. Also Love Theme From Romeo And Juliet (A Time For Us), Aquarius/Let The Sunshine In, Without Her, Live For Life, We, Didn't We, Love Me Tonight, The Windmills Of Your Mind, The World I Threw Away, Yesterday When I Was Young. Shrink wrap partially torn

 

Johnny Mathis

Romeo And Juliet / 1969 / Columbia CS 9909

VG++ / VG+ / $11.00

Original release, "360 Stereo" on label. Love Theme From Romeo And Juliet (A Time For Us), Aquarius/Let The Sunshine In, Without Her, I"ll Never Fall In Love Again, Live For Life, We, Didn't We, Love Me Tonight, The Windmills Of Your Mind, The World I Threw Away, Yesterday When I Was Young. Shrink wrap partially torn

 

Johnny Mathis

Johnny Mathis Sings The Music of Bacharach & Kaempfert (2 LPs) / 1970 / Columbia CG 30350

VG++ / VG+, VG+ / $15.00Record sold

The Look Of Love, I'll Never Fall In Love Again, Strangers In The Night, Danke Schoen, Walk On By, Wonderland By Night, The Times Will Change, Don't Stay, The Lady Smiles, Remember When, If There's A Way, L-O-V-E, Faithfully, Heavenly, Lady, I Say A Little Prayer, This Guy's In Love With You, Odds And Ends, Don't Go Breakin' My Heart, Alfie, Spanish Eyes

 

Johnny Mathis - People

Johnny Mathis

People / 1970? / Columbia CS 9871

NM is / VG++ / $12.50Record sold

The Shadow Of Your Smile, More, What The World Needs Now Is Love, Sunny, Autumn Leaves, Laura, Quiet Nights Of Quiet Stars, Elusive Butterfly, A Wonderful Day Like Today, People

 

Johnny Mathis (more Sealed albums)

Close To You / 1970 / Columbia C30210

Sealed / $20.00Record sold

Original release. They Long To Be Close to You, Evil Ways, Come Saturday Morning, Yellow Days, Pieces Of Dreams, Song Of Joy, Everything Is Beautiful, The Long And Winding Road, Why Can't I Touch You?, Wave, Until It's Time For You To Go

 

New arrival Johnny Mathis

Love Story / 1971 / Columbia C 30499

VG+ / VG+ / $12.00

Original release. (Where Do I Begin) Love Story, Rose Garden, Ten Times Forever More, It's Impossible, I Was There, What Are You Doing The Rest Of Your Life, We've Only Just Begun, Traces, For The Good Times, My Sweet Lord, Loss Of Love

 

Johnny Mathis

You've Got A Friend / 1971 / Columbia C30740

NM / VG++ / $14.00Record sold

Original release. You've Got A Friend, How Can You Mend A Broken Heart, Help Me Make It Through The Night, If You Could Read My Mind, Never Can Say Goodbye, It's Too Late, We Can Work It Out, Long Ago And Far Away, If, For All We Know, If We Only Have Love

 

Johnny Mathis

All-Time Greatest Hits (2 LPs) / 1972 / Columbia KG 31345

NM / NM, NM / $20.00Record sold

20 greats including Chances Are, Wonderful Wonderful, When Sunny Gets Blue, A Certain Smile, All The Time, Wild Is The Wind, Gina, Misty Roses, Venus, What Will My Mary Say, My Funny Valentine, Love Theme From Romeo & Juliet, Come To Me, Love Story (Where Do I Begin), If We Only Have Love, Misty

 

Johnny Mathis

All-Time Greatest Hits (2 LPs) / 197? / Columbia PG 31345

VG++ / VG++, NM / $16.00

'70s reissue, no barcode on back cover. 20 greats including Chances Are, Wonderful Wonderful, When Sunny Gets Blue, A Certain Smile, All The Time, Wild Is The Wind, Gina, Misty Roses, Venus, What Will My Mary Say, My Funny Valentine, Love Theme From Romeo & Juliet, Come To Me, Love Story (Where Do I Begin), If We Only Have Love, Misty

 

Johnny Mathis All-Time Greatest Hits

Johnny Mathis

All-Time Greatest Hits (2 LPs) / 198? / Columbia PG 31345

VG++ / VG++, VG++ / $15.00

Reissue with barcode on back cover. 20 greats including Chances Are, Wonderful Wonderful, When Sunny Gets Blue, A Certain Smile, All The Time, Wild Is The Wind, Gina, Misty Roses, Venus, What Will My Mary Say, My Funny Valentine, Love Theme From Romeo & Juliet, Come To Me, Love Story (Where Do I Begin), If We Only Have Love, Misty

 

Johnny Mathis - Christmas with Johnny Mathis & Percy Faith Johnny Mathis/Percy Faith - Christmas with Johnny Mathis & Percy Faith

Johnny Mathis / Percy Faith (more Christmas albums) (more Sealed albums)

Christmas With Johnny Mathis / Christmas With Percy Faith / 1973 / Columbia Special Products P 11805

Sealed / $35.00Record sold

Mathis (Side 1) sings Sleigh Ride, What Child Is This, Jingle Bell Rock, Silver Bells, Silent Night. Faith (Side 2) plays O Come All Ye Faithful, It Came Upon A Midnight Clear, Good King Wenceslas, O Holy Night, Joy To The World

 

Johnny Mathis

Killing Me Softly With His Song / 1973 / Columbia KC 32258

Sealed / $20.00Record sold

Original release

 

Johnny Mathis

I'm Coming Home / 1973 / Columbia KC 32435

VG++ / NM / $15.00

I'm Coming Home, I'd Rather Be Here With You, Foolish, I'm Stone In Love With You, And I Think That's What I'll Do, Life Is A Song Worth SInging, A Baby's Born, Sweet Child, Stop Look And Listen To Your Heart, I Just Wanted To Be Me

 

Johnny Mathis

Johnny's Greatest Hits / 1977 / Columbia PC 34667

VG+ / VG++ / $11.00

Reissue with new cover art. Chances Are, All The Time, The Twelfth Of Never, When Sunny Gets Blue, When I Am With You, Wonderful! Wonderful!, It's Not For Me To Say, Come to Me, Wild Is The Wind, Warm And Tender, No Love, I Look At You

 

Johnny Mathis

Feelings / 1975 / Columbia PC 33887

VG++ / VG++ / $14.00Record sold

99 Miles From L.A., Solitaire, Stardust, One Day In Your Life, Feelings, What I Did For Love, The Greatest Gift, Hurry Mother Nature, That's All She Wrote, Midnight Blue

 

Johnny Mathis

I Only Have Eyes For You / 1976 / CBS/Sony 25AP 115

NM is / VG+ / $15.00

Japanese release, with insert in Japanese and English. Factory sticker on shrink promotes When A Child Is Born. Also I Write The Songs, Do Me Wrong But Do Me, The Hungry Years, I Only Have Eyes For You, Yellow Roses On Her Gown, Do You Know Where You're Going To (Theme From Mahogany), Ooh What We Do, Send In The Clowns, Every Time You Touch Me (I Get High)

 

Johnny Mathis

Mathis Is ... / 1977 / Columbia PC 34411

VG++ / NM / $14.00

As Long As We're Together, Lullaby Of Love, Loving You - Losing You, I'll Make You Happy, Heaven Must Have Made You Just For Me, Hung Up In The Middle Of Love, World Of Laughter, I Don't Want To Say No, Sweet Love Of Mine

 

Johnny Mathis

You Light Up My Life / 1978 / Columbia JC-35259

VG++ / VG+ / $8.00Record sold

 

Johnny Mathis

Mathis Magic / 1979 / Columbia JC 36216

NM is / VG++ / $12.00

No One But The One You Love, Night And Day, Love, My Body Keeps Changing My Mind, New York State Of Mind, She Believes In Me, That Old Black Magic, You Saved My Life, To The Ends Of The Earth, Heart Soul Body And Mind

 

New arrival Johnny Mathis

Different Kinda Different / 1980 / Columbia JC 36505

VG++ / NM / $12.00

Vinyl like new. Different Kinda Different (duet with Paulette), With You I'm Born Again, I'll Do It All For You (duet with Paulette), Never Givin' Up On You, Deep Purple, I Will Survive, Paradise, The Lights Of Rio, Love Without Words, Temptation

 

Johnny Mathis

The First 25 Years - The Silver Anniversary Album (2 LPs) / 1981 / Columbia C2X 37440

VG++ / VG+, VG+ / $10.00 Record sold

Misty, Begin The Beguine, Didn't We, It Doesn't Have To Hurt Everytime, Wonderful Wonderful, It's Not For Me To Say, Stardust, Three Times A Lady, The Way You Look Tonight, Deep Purple, Chances Are, All The Things You Are, A Time For Us, Nothing Between Us But Love, There I've Said It Again,Too Much Too Little Too Late, As Time Goes By, When Sunny Gets Blue, Ready Or Not, I'm Coming Home. Gatefold cover with multiple photos of the artist

 

Johnny Mathis

Friends In Love / 1982 / Columbia FC 37748

VG++ / NM / $12.00

Promo stamp on back cover. With Dionne Warwick on Friends In Love and Got You Where I Want You. Also: I Remember You And Me, When The Lovin' Goes Out Of The Lovin', Somethin's Goin' On,What Do You Do With The Love, What's Forever For, Warm, Memory (theme from "Cats"), Lately.

 

Johnny Mathis

The First Time (Ever I Saw Your Face) / 198? / Columbia PC 31342

Sealed / $15.00Record sold

Reissue

 

Johnny Mathis

A Special Part Of Me / 1984 / Columbia FC 38718

NM / NM / $12.50

Custom inner sleeve with credits. Arranged by Michel Colombier. Simple, Love Won't Let Me Wait (with Deniece Williams), The Best Is Yet To Come, Lead Me To Your Love, You're A Special Part Of Me (with Angela Bofill), Love Never Felt So Good, Priceless, One Love, Right Here And Now

 

Johnny Mathis - For Christmas

Johnny Mathis (more Christmas records)

For Christmas / 1984 / Columbia PC 39468

VG++ is / VG++ / $25.00Record sold

The Little Drummer Boy, The Lord's Prayer, Do You Hear What I Hear, God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen, Carol Of The Bells, Have Yorself A Merry Little Christmas, Jingle Bell Rock, Santa Claus Is Comin' To Town, Rudolph The Red Nosed Reindeer, Let It Snow Let It Snow Let It Snow. Includes inner sleeve with lyrics

Johnny Mathis (more Christmas records)

Christmas Eve With Johnny Mathis / 1986 / Columbia C 40447

VG++ / VG++ / $10.00

 

Johnny Mathis (more Christmas records)

Christmas Eve With Johnny Mathis / 1986 / Columbia FC 30447

NM is / VG++ / $11.00

 

Johnny Mathis

In The Still Of The Night / 1989 / Columbia OC 44336

VG++ / VG++ / $15.00Record sold

In The Still Of The Night, It's All In The Game, Sonce I Fell For You, You Belong To Me, True Love Ways, Since I Don't Have You, Then You Can Tell Me Goodbye, The End Of The World, All Alone Am I, For Your Love

 

Johnny Mathis fans - check out The Mathis Chronicles!

Grading standards/terms

Home / order